Procurement and sourcing
Awarding each line to the cheapest bid ignores freight, capacity and risk. We award your whole basket at once, at the lowest total cost.
- Free 30-minute call
- No commitment
- You own the code
In short: A sourcing award optimisation decides which supplier delivers which items in a tender. It looks at all items in the tender at once. It weighs prices, bundle discounts, freight, supplier capacity and supply risk to find the lowest total cost.
The problem
The tender closes on Friday, and the bids are in a spreadsheet, one row per line, meaning each item you want to buy. You sort each row by unit price and mark the cheapest supplier. By Monday the award is signed: the decision on who supplies what. Three months later, freight costs more than planned and one supplier can’t keep up. Another bills you because you bought less than you agreed.
At first glance, choosing suppliers looks like a price comparison. Yet the cheapest unit price can cost the most once you add freight, tooling, payment terms and defect rates. Depending on one source adds a cost of its own, which you only see the day that supplier’s plant goes down.
Signs your awards cost more than they show
You award line by line, on unit price. Freight and quality costs turn up later, in another department’s budget. A supplier’s capacity gets checked after the award, not before. You promised a supplier to buy a minimum volume each year. You only notice when the invoice for the missing volume arrives. And a critical item depends on a single supplier.
Why line-by-line awarding fails
The naive approach awards each line to the cheapest bid and hopes the rest sorts itself out. You miss bundle discounts that suppliers only offer for a whole product family. A cheap supplier gets pushed past capacity, which forces a panicked re-award. A supplier you promised a minimum volume gets less than that, and you pay the agreed penalty. A spreadsheet that settles one line at a time can’t see any of this.
What changes
Today, you award each line to the cheapest bid and fix the problems afterwards. Our model awards the whole basket at once. It counts the full cost of each bid, keeps every supplier within capacity and handles every volume commitment. You decide across how many suppliers you split an item, so that one failure doesn’t leave you without goods. The model shows what that costs.
Sourcing award optimisation spreads everything you buy across suppliers so the whole basket costs least. At the same time, it keeps every supplier’s capacity, your contracts and your rule for spreading risk. In the end, you have suppliers that are cheap as a group and still keep you supplied when one of them fails.
What you get
We build your procurement optimisation model on your own bids, your total costs and your constraints. Capacity, commitments and contracts are all in. Before anything goes live, we test it on your past spend and on the supplier failures you fear most. You sign the award knowing how it behaves when things go wrong.
- A model written around your own procurement and sourcing rules.
- Results measured in the numbers you already track.
- It slots into how you already work, and you can check every answer it gives.
How it works
Forecasts, stock and decisions about your warehouse network go into one model instead of three spreadsheets. By network we mean all your warehouses, distribution centres and branches, and which site supplies which. The model plans forecasts, stock and network decisions together in a single run. So a fix in one warehouse no longer creates a new problem at another site.
Sourcing as a combinatorial auction
The most useful frame is a combinatorial auction: a tender where suppliers can bid on combinations of lines. In a standard tender, suppliers bid a price for each line, and you award each line separately. That’s how the spreadsheet works too, and that’s how you miss bundle discounts.
In a combinatorial auction, suppliers can bid on bundles. “Give us lines A, B and C together, and the price drops.” Your job becomes the winner-determination problem. Which set of bids covers every line at the lowest total cost, under every constraint you face? The number of valid combinations grows so fast that no person can check them all. Our model searches them systematically and finds the cheapest valid set. That search is what combinatorial auction optimisation means.
A worked example: three lines, two suppliers
Take a small tender for 1,000 units each of lines A, B and C. Supplier X bids 10, 10 and 12 francs per unit, or 9.50 across the board for all three. Supplier Y bids 10.50, 9.50 and 11. Freight adds 0.50 per unit from X and 1 franc from Y, and Y can make 1,500 units at most.
Line by line on unit price, A goes to X, while B and C go to Y. That’s 33,000 francs with freight, and it gives Y 2,000 units it can’t make. Awarded as a basket, everything goes to X at the bundle price for 30,000 francs. Nothing in the bids changed. Only the way you read them did.
Total cost of ownership
The example only works because “cost” includes freight. Total cost of ownership (TCO) replaces the unit price with what each award costs you by the time the goods arrive. It adds freight and handling. It adds one-off costs for tools and setup, divided by the number of units. It also counts payment terms, expected defects and returns, and what a long delivery time costs you. Supplier selection optimisation scores every quote on that TCO.
Commitments, capacity and contracts
Contract obligations are usually checked only after the award. They belong in the model from the start. If you promised a supplier a minimum volume per year, it bills you for every missing unit. So the model gives that supplier enough volume. Or it accepts the penalty on purpose, where that’s cheaper. No supplier can take more than its production lines, plant or raw material allow, however good the price.
Contracts add their own rules. Some protect your current suppliers, some require two sources for a line, and some require a share from one region. The model treats all of these as constraints, rules every award must keep. So the award keeps every contract, and you don’t have to fix it by hand afterwards.
Dual-sourcing and risk
Dual-sourcing protects you best against a supplier failure. You split a line’s volume across two approved suppliers. Give everything to one cheap supplier, and you pay the lowest unit price. But if its plant goes down or it delivers faulty goods, you have none of that item left.
With two suppliers, you pay a surcharge, and you know it in advance. In return, you still get goods when one supplier fails. The model shows what each split costs. In a 70/30 split, one supplier delivers 70 of every 100 units and the other 30. In a 50/50 split, each delivers 50. You choose the split whose surcharge you are willing to pay. If losing your main supplier would stop one of your production lines, we usually recommend splitting across two suppliers: a day of downtime often costs more than the premium.
Joint optimisation with MILP
Joint optimisation solves the award as one problem. The method is mixed-integer linear programming (MILP). It mixes yes-or-no choices, such as giving this line to this supplier, with quantities, such as how many units each supplier gets. It minimises total cost of ownership across the basket, within capacity, commitments, contracts and your risk rule. You get the combination that is cheapest overall, bundle discounts and penalties included.
Why the award comes first
The award comes first: only once you know which supplier delivers what can you plan production, stock and transport. It decides which suppliers feed which plants and distribution centres, and over which transport lanes. So it’s tangled up with supply chain network design. For manufacturers, it decides whether a plant runs short of material or gets more than it can store.
Common questions.
Something else? Ask us directly.
Start with the unit price, then add freight and handling. Add the one-off costs for tooling and setup, divided by the number of units you order. Count how late you may pay, how many faulty parts you expect and what returns cost. A longer lead time costs too, because you usually need more safety stock. Two quotes with the same unit price can differ a lot in total. Total cost of ownership (TCO) shows that gap before you award the contract.
Only if you let them, so say so in the tender. Many suppliers save money when they get a whole product family: they set up their machines once and fill their trucks better. Until now, they couldn’t pass that saving on as a lower price for the whole package. The model works with whatever comes back, single-line bids included. Package bids are an option for suppliers, never a requirement.
Compare two amounts: what a second supplier costs you extra, and what a supply failure would cost you. Buying the same part from two suppliers (dual sourcing) usually costs more per unit, because each supplier gets less volume. If a missing part would stop a production line or lose a big customer, that premium is cheap insurance. For a part you can buy elsewhere within days, single sourcing at the best price is often fine.
Sometimes it can, and if that’s the case, we’ll tell you. Standard software is built for an average operation, though. Yours runs on its own rules: your contracts, your exceptions, the things you know by heart. A custom model writes those rules in, and that’s where the better plan comes from.
You don’t need either to start. We build the model from the data you’ve already got, even if it lives in three spreadsheets and one person’s head. You get a system you run yourself. We train your team until they no longer need us.
You see a first result with the prototype, before you commit to anything bigger. We start with a free 30-minute call about your operation and the model that would fit it. Then we build a working prototype and run it on your numbers.
Similar pages.
Terms on this page
Every abbreviation explained in plain words, in our article “Metrics and methods”.
Tell us what you’re planning.
In a free 30-minute call with a specialist, you find out whether optimisation can help.
- Free, no commitment
- You talk to a specialist directly
- A clear go or no-go